|
| ||||||||||||||||||

| From | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
|
noob81 17-Feb-12, 00:11 |
Comment deleted on 19-Feb-12, 14:30.
|
||
|
edwardbutler 17-Feb-12, 00:12 » Report abuse |
![]() |
||
|
eightofwands 17-Feb-12, 00:49 |
Comment deleted on 19-Feb-12, 14:30.
|
||
» Report abuse |
Gameknot need to screen the front page puzzlesFair play to chesskingdeluxe (no longer a member), it must have taken them quite a bit longer for them to make this than it has for any one to solve it. This is not a puzzle, more of an demonstration of how not to make a puzzle. Anyone get the feeling the feeling we are not happy about this "puzzle" (my son likes it though, he´s finished a puzzle). |
||
|
mihaimarinescu 17-Feb-12, 02:11 » Report abuse |
![]() |
||
|
chaswil 17-Feb-12, 04:44 |
Comment deleted on 19-Feb-12, 14:30.
|
||
» Report abuse |
![]() |
||
» Report abuse |
So Easy... |
||
» Report abuse |
![]() |
||
» Report abuse |
oh my god |
||
|
dikaios1 17-Feb-12, 09:29 » Report abuse |
![]() |
||
|
rich_sposato 17-Feb-12, 10:19 » Report abuse |
![]() Even a zero star rating is too much. |
||
» Report abuse |
![]() |
||
» Report abuse |
![]() |
||
» Report abuse |
why so serious? |
||
|
zavala 17-Feb-12, 15:17 |
Comment deleted on 19-Feb-12, 14:30.
|
||
|
dracoargentum 17-Feb-12, 15:34 » Report abuse |
![]() |
||
» Report abuse |
Easy for some, not for othersLike macheide said, don't be so rude. I'll add, don't be so arrogant. |
||
|
woutstra 17-Feb-12, 18:24 » Report abuse |
![]() |
||
|
hcajg77 17-Feb-12, 18:41 » Report abuse |
Easy puzzles |
||
|
babe2luv 17-Feb-12, 19:29 |
Comment deleted on 19-Feb-12, 14:30.
|
||
|
rich_sposato 17-Feb-12, 22:53 » Report abuse |
![]() One reason many people complain about the puzzle is that it is too easy. Not just easy - but too easy. It does not teach any tactics. It does not provide insight into understanding chess. It has no subtlety. I've seen some good 6 move easy puzzles, but this is not one of them. |
||
» Report abuse |
too easy? |
||
» Report abuse |
Maybe not a puzzle, but funny... |
||
|
hcajg77 19-Feb-12, 06:52 » Report abuse |
![]() rich_sposato, I've said it before, but I'll say it again. It's called an easy puzzle for a reason. It doesn't have to be to hard. Easy puzzles are supposed to be easy. |
||
|
rich_sposato 19-Feb-12, 12:29 » Report abuse |
![]() hcajg77, whether people call this too easy or just easy probably depends on their skill level. Maybe instead of rating puzzles from 1 to 5 stars (which is subjective since what I call 4 stars, some 2200 level player might call 2 stars), let's consider if GameKnot rated puzzles by the level of whomever solves them. Gameknot does that for tactics. A puzzle like this might get an 800 rating since the majority of 800 level players should be able to solve this one blindfolded. Another puzzle may deserve a 2100 level if it stumps most people less than 2100. That way instead of seeing lots of complaints that the puzzle is stupid, too easy, or ugly, anybody over 800 would just skip it as not worth their time. If I could magically refactor GameKnot to rate puzzles by level, I'd only deal with puzzles rated 1500 or higher. |
||
» Report abuse |
bad sample |
||
» Report abuse |
bad sample,You can see Rich speaks sense on the rating and in this little gameknot community etc etc |
||
» Report abuse |
![]() |
||
|
george2003 07-Mar-12, 16:43 » Report abuse |
![]() Distraction? |
Please log in |