ANNOTATED GAME

Malpas & Oswestry 2 Vs Chester J
Andrew Williams (ECF38) vs. Kareem Ghatwary
Annotated by: charleshiggie (2222)
Chess opening: Queen's pawn, Mason variation (D00)
Interactive Show all comments All annotated games View chessboard as:
Pages: 12345
1. d4
I am annotating this for one of my team mates, Andrew "Willy" Williams.
2 comments
 
1... d5
He plays on Gameknot as "knight_nite".

 
2. Bf4
This line is called the Mason Varation. https://www.365chess.com/eco/D00_Queen's_pawn_Mason_variation
2 comments
 
2... Nc6
Sound development, but this move blocks the c pawn and prevents c7-c6 to support the c pawn and the counter-attacking c7-c5. 2....Nf6 is most commonly played, and I think is best.
2 comments
 
3. Nf3
Sound development by Willy.

 
3... Bf5
...and by black.

 
4. e3
Yes, that is what I would have played.
4 comments
 
4... Nf6
Good development by black. The raid 4....Nb4, threatening c2 doesn't come to much, white can simply play 5. Na3 and then drive the knight back with c2-c3.
1 comment
 
5. c3
A good, solid move by white. I quite like white's set-up. The Bf4 has been developed outside the pawn chain, and then the centre pawns placed on black squares. This seems to be a logical developing move, but Gameknot thinks it is a mistake. http://gameknot.com/analyze-board.pl?bd=5951167&rnd=0.4397394524167513
4 comments
 
5... e6
Black too is making sensible moves.

 
6. h3
This not really a mistake, but I don't see the need for it. I think white would be better advised to continue to develop.
4 comments
 
6... Bd6
Black plays to exchange dark squared bishops(DSB). One could argue that for black his DSB is the good bishop as it is on the opposite colour to his central pawns, so it can weave in and out of them, while for white the DSB is the bad bishop, as it is on the same coloured squared as his central pawns. However in this case the white DSB is developed outside the pawn chain, so is not really "bad".
2 comments
 
7. g4
A bold advance by white. This has been played before in iceman32682 (1729) vs. josefgor (1556) http://gameknot.com/analyze-board.pl?bd=5951167&mv=13&rnd=0.3453198403913642
2 comments
 
7... Be4
As played by josefgor (1556)
1 comment
 
8. Nbd2
8. Bd3 was played by iceman, but this move looks good, developing the knight and attacking the bishop. In fact the Gameknot computer thinks that 8. Bd3 is a mistake and 8. Nbd2 is stronger. http://gameknot.com/analyze-board.pl?bd=5951167&rnd=0.4397394524167513
2 comments
 
8... e5
Black tries to exploit the pin on the Nf3 to force through this move which is positionally desirable, but actually there is a flaw in the idea. Simply 0-0 and preparing e6-e5 with Re8 was better.
2 comments
 
9. dxe5
Yes, I think this is best move. Usually in these sorts of positions it is best to start by taking with the piece of the lowest value, i.e. a pawn.

 
9... Bxe5
Black takes back.

 
10. Nxe4
White takes the bishop that was pinning the Nf3. If black now recaptures the knight with, say 10....dxe4 then 11. Nxe5 and white has won a piece. White may consider taking the queens off with check first too.
1 comment
 
10... Bxf4
So black tries this.
2 comments
 

Pages: 12345