ANNOTATED GAME

Tutorial Game
goldmedal10 (619) vs. boredqueen (908)
Annotated by: archduke_piccolo (2337)
Chess opening: Mieses opening (A00)
Interactive Show all comments All annotated games View chessboard as:
Pages: 12
This was the latest (to date) game by the player of the White pieces. She is learning, and at present on a losing streak. Apart from still having to shed the tendency to leave pieces and pawns hanging, I thought I would use this game to inquire more closely into the way she plays. In fact, with the occasional question mark, White is well in the game until her 15th move. At that point she even had a deadly shot that might well have ended the game at once. Instead, it all went turnip-shaped within 2 more moves.
1. d3
An unassuming beginning - almost shy - but it is also non-committal and flexible. Nothing wrong with this.
1 comment
 
1... e6
Equally cagey. Black frees diagonals for Q and B to develop.

 
2. Nf3
Good development.
1 comment
 
2... Bc5
Brings the bishop to a 'natural' square, eyeing f2, Not that f2 is in any danger yet, but White could poke the bishop in the eye with 3.d4, forcing it to move again. White would not need to worry about 3...Bb4ch as 4.c3 to block the check would be good and solid.
1 comment
 
3. e3
Creating a 'small centre'. Blocks the bishop's line to f2, and frees the King's bishop to develop to e2, if White so wishes. I prefer 3.d4, but this is fine.
1 comment
 
3... Qf6
Suddenly Black shows ambition! She hasn't given up hope that an opportunity might yet develop against f2, and there is also a chance that something interesting might appear on b2. Ironically, Black was later to overlook a very real chance at f2, and the b2-square ought to have proved fatal for her. You'll just have to wait and see... But seriously, Black would have been better off (objectively speaking) developing a knight to f6 instead.
1 comment
 
4. Be2
OK: consistent.

 
4... d5
Staking a bigger claim on the centre. Good play. Having set up the Q-B lines against f2, Black doesn't press the matter, but reverts to developing sensibly. Note that Black had plenty of good moves available: ...d5 was one of them.

 
5. Bd2
Now, I doubt White had seen through the implications of this development; but if she did, it was very clever of her. Now the b2-pawn is left unprotected, and Black might well have said to herself: 'Ooo, yummy: free pawn!" and played 5...Qxb2, with the tasty prospect of winning the a1-rook. fen="rnb1k1nr/ppp2ppp/4p3/2bp4/8/3PPN2/PqPBBPPP/RN1QK2R w KQkq -" But White would have had a counter-attack ready: 6.Bc3!! ... The bishop attacks the queen and THROUGH THE QUEEN protected the rook. After 6...Qb6, say, then comes 7.Bxg7 ... and 8.Bxh8 and it is White who wins a rook. In fact, Black would probably be better off exchanging Queen for Rook and hope to save the game. To recap: 5...Qxb2?? 6.Bc3 Qxa1 7.Bxa1 ... and White is the major exchange ahead. Not for nothing is the b2-pawn called the 'poisoned pawn'!
3 comments
 
5... d4
Rightly passing up the b2-bait. But this move isn't very good either. Although it has as many defenders (bishop and queen) as White has attackers against it (pawn and knight), that pawn is not safe at all. Black would have been much better advised to move one of her undeveloped minor pieces.
1 comment
 
6. exd4
Well played! White wins a pawn. Perfectly OK and safe would have been 6.e4, but in my view this capture is best. See next note.

 
6... Bb6
Quite rightly Black leaves the d-pawn strictly alone. Had she recaptured, a bit of a melee might have developed: 6...Bxd4 7.Nxd4 Qxd4 8.Bc3! ... (attacking the queen, and through the queen {this is called a skewer} attacks the g7-pawn {and the h8-rook behind it} as well. Black has but one good move to deal with this;) 8...Qd5! (Now, if White plays 9.Bxg7, Black goes 9...Qxg2! attacking White's rook and g7-bishop both. White COULD press on with this line, but would probably be better to cut out here, BEFORE Black gets to play ...Qxg2:) 9.Bf3! Qg4 (Guards g7) 10.h4 Qg6 with a fine game for White. fen="rnb1k1nr/ppp2ppp/4p1q1/8/7P/2BP1B2/PPP2PP1/RN1QK2R w KQkq -"
2 comments
 
7. Nc3
Developing the last minor piece. White is doing great, here: development almost complete, well centralised, solid position, a pawn ahead. Could it be objected that Black could now snitch the d-pawn? Actually no: 7...Bxd4 8.Ne4! - By attacking the bishop's sole protector, the knight drives away the queen, leaving the bishop to be taken for nothing. Black's best option then would be to 'sell' the bishop for what it will fetch: 8...Bxf2ch 9.Kxf2 - and Black then has time to save the queen.
2 comments
 
7... e5
Not a good move, as Black should lose a second pawn for nothing. Possibly Black is trying to open the lines against f2.
1 comment
 
8. dxe5
The better capture, as after 8.Nxe5 Bxd4 9.Nf3 ... White remains just one pawn ahead. Now White is two pawns to the good, has a powerful centre, and Black is forced to spend time attending to her queen.
1 comment
 
8... Qc6 9. Ng5
This is where White starts to go wrong, I think. It is understandable that with development complete, White wants to set up a plan. Did she have a trap in mind? 9...Qxg2(??) 10.Bf3, winning the Queen? It doesn't work, for then comes 10...Qxf2 Checkmate! I think I would have preferred to castle or play 9.d4. So this knight move looks like a mistake.
2 comments
 
9... Qc5
Threatens checkmate, but, much stronger would have been 9...Qxg2, attacking the rook on h1 and threatening mate on f2. White's only defence would have been 10.Rf1, saving the rook and defending f2. Fortunately the g5-knight is defended already. But Black would have equalised the game.
2 comments
 
10. Na4
?? I can see the idea here - and the motif (attacking Q and B lined up in this way) is a very familiar one. But White has overlooked something terminal - 10...Qxf2#! Much, much stronger would have been simply to castle, and if Black were to take the e-pawn (10.0-0 Qxe5), White has a tremendous tactical shot: 11.Bg4!! It has to be admitted, this one's a bit more arcane, but leaving that aside, White would be well on top. The simpler 11.Re1 comes more easily to mind, would be almost as strong, with nasty threats down the e-file.
1 comment
 
10... Qd5
Having set up the checkmate - at such great risk, too - why did Black not play it? 10...Qxf2#. No further comment needed here!
1 comment
 
11. Bf3
OK, but the simplest would have been to end all further threats against f2 by 11.Nxb6. Castling was a very good alternative.
1 comment
 

Pages: 12