Play online chess!

A cheater at Gameknot.
« Back to club forum
Pages: 123456
Go to the last post
FromMessage
wasatch
18-Mar-24, 07:56

Computer analysis complete
game

So, he did make some errors. My take is he was playing on his own, got in trouble, and then went to the computer and it finished quickly. He is learning to hide his tracks, somewhat.

I’m doubling my efforts to inform everyone.

lord_shiva
18-Mar-24, 08:11

Prat Fall Points


What 1500 rated player does not immediately recognize the threat here? Black must play Bd6 or something to defend against Nxc7+. Instead black plays a6?

game

By the way, Cat vs. Plant is now puzzle #292170
lord_shiva
18-Mar-24, 08:19

Wasatch
Good call.



In my quick review I overlooked e5. Also f6. Qxd4 fails, and I stopped with that.
perfect_spy
05-Aug-24, 12:36

Another cheater
game

Keeps his ratings low by resigning games he’s winning.
wasatch
05-Aug-24, 13:08

Perfect_spy, has anyone reported this guy to his team captain?

…with the idea that if the offender is not removed, other teams avoid matching with them?

This seems to be the only real defense we have in team play, at least.

perfect_spy
05-Aug-24, 14:20

He wins team games and Tournament games but loses most others to keep his rating down so he can make the Finals of GK Tournaments. I reported him to GK but heard nothing back. I’ll send his team captain a message, but all this cheater will do is join another team.
wasatch
05-Aug-24, 18:04

@perfect_spy:

Then you chase him down at the new team. I have chased one cheater off GK (stormtracker) and busy chasing catseye/imapirate now. I will eventually get him tossed or wear him out to where he’ll quit too.
perfect_spy
06-Aug-24, 02:01

I’ve messaged the team captain and he says he will look into it.
saguaro
06-Aug-24, 09:28

Which one?
Is it migeri or archiphile?
perfect_spy
06-Aug-24, 09:34

Migeri. He quits games in winning positions after 10 or 11 moves.
lord_shiva
06-Aug-24, 17:18

Migeri
migeri

game Resigns with free queen
game Let’s play

Still playing for Phoenix. Plenty of other questionable games, not just these.
perfect_spy
07-Aug-24, 04:42

His team captain said they will monitor his games, assuming it means team games. Alas it’s not these type of games he’s throwing. I doubt any conclusion will arise.
wasatch
07-Aug-24, 06:56

@Perfect_spy

OK, you Captains need to NOT play this team…and let their Captain know they are in the penalty box for abetting a cheater.

This is the only way to protect your teams since GK will not police their members.

It really is up to you.
lord_shiva
07-Aug-24, 09:58

Old Habits
are hard to break. Pirate (imapirate) is still at it, though no longer on any team.

game
riaannieman
07-Aug-24, 23:44

I did a quick check of the last ten personal games of migeri. He doesn't use algorithms that my platform can detect. But I only checked 10 games because I am hard pressed for time. An analyses of a large sample of his games must be done to determine trends, habits and the use of chess algorithms.
beard1720
08-Aug-24, 01:53

I have spoken to Migeri and asked him to give assurances that he tries in all games and if he cannot do that, it will be better for him to leave the team.
I do not want this to affect our reputation within the Gameknot community.

Beard
lord_shiva
08-Aug-24, 08:30

Thanks Pete!
We will monitor him. In the meantime, it might be best to avoid assigning matches until his real rating is established.
lord_shiva
08-Aug-24, 08:32

Rating Manipulation
Thanks, Riaan. So he is playing his natural skill in team games but just represses his rating in private and tournament games.

That analysis was fast.
wasatch
08-Aug-24, 08:43

Ok, I posted some cheater criteria in another thread. I need to add a team win percentage above 60%…so Migeri meets 3 of 6 of the criteria.

…I contend that Migeri bears heavy watching.

…I’m now going to look at some of his wins.
lord_shiva
08-Aug-24, 08:43

Games
In this game Migeri is ahead four points against a player with a rating 100 points higher. By itself that doesn’t mean anything, of course—we have all beaten players who outrank us by even wider margins on a good day. But it is indicative of his true skill level. He fortunately has only four team games running at the moment.

game



In the same match he is down two points as black.

perfect_spy
08-Aug-24, 08:55

Here’s one to look at
game

Now why would you resign if you are +17 pts up?


wasatch
08-Aug-24, 09:12

@perfect_spy

Simple, He is using league games to lower his rating…

…so that he gets a rating advantage for his team games.

If I were running a team, I would NOT play any matches with his team, period. If they allow Migeri, they will allow others.
perfect_spy
08-Aug-24, 09:15

GK Tournaments
Also he does quite well in these tournaments, placed on the podium at least four times.


wasatch
08-Aug-24, 09:18

“Also he does quite well in these tournaments, placed on the podium at least four times.”

Yes! One of my 6 cheater criteria (in another thread)
beard1720
08-Aug-24, 09:22

wasatch
I think you are being a bit harsh on us as a team, just because you have been watching Migeri.

I have, as I have said, approached him and will not be giving him any more team games until he has proven himself

saguaro
08-Aug-24, 09:50

@beard
Agreed. Let's focus on migeri.

Although you are more patient than I. When I determined that players were manipulating, I dropped them immediately, not wanting any unfairness on the team.
wasatch
08-Aug-24, 11:58

@beard1720

I suggest you read thru the postings here on how hard it is to get GK to do anything about these clowns who cheat. Perhaps then…you might realize the ONLY method of control team captains have is to work thru other team captains.

In other words, you have to police yourselves.

I’m not on any teams but we have similar problems “policing” tournament players and in that case hardly anyone else thinks it is their problem. At least you team members have an effective method thru mutual common interest.

…sorry if it came across as harsh.
riaannieman
11-Aug-24, 23:52

Don't crucify beard1720 because of one of his players. He has assured us he is taking steps. Let us give him some time to work the problem.

SWAT has not played a lot with the Phoenixes, but the games we did play ended well for us all. As long as beard1720 keeps an eye on his players, I am still happy to take challenges from them.
gmforsythe
12-Aug-24, 03:56

Riaan re beard1720
I totally agree. I challenged him immediately upon seeing his message here, and we got a match going.

George
wasatch
12-Aug-24, 06:42

Ok, I apologized.

As for the rest of you, please realize that migeri’s team win % is 63%.

That is extremely hard to do without “help”.
Pages: 123456
Go to the last post



GameKnot: play chess online, online chess puzzles, monthly chess tournaments, Internet chess league, chess teams, chess clubs, free online chess games database and more.