GameKnot related: Advanced Player Search
« Back to forum
FromMessage
lord_shiva
09-Apr-15, 15:27

Advanced Player Search
The players ADVANCED search feature would benefit by two new options.

1. Team: Doesn't matter Yes No
2. Green Dot (eligible for games): Doesn't matter Yes No

While I cannot think of why anyone might want to search for players NOT eligible for games, the "doesn't matter" and "yes" options are necessary.

1. Team (the player is a member of a team). This would improve player recruitment by eliminating players already on teams.

1 & 2 combined would greatly assist team captains in arranging matches.
lord_shiva
03-Nov-15, 10:09

Team Rating
You might think the Team Rating would weed out (or include) candidates who are members of a team, but it does not. It does help--but a lot of players without any team affiliation still retain a team rating.

Just how much trouble would it be to include a green dot (eligible) and team member option?

It's been half a year since this was first proposed. How often does GK roll out new features?

Also, is there a forum topic or place where we can see what GK is working on currently?
lord_shiva
01-Sep-18, 05:35

Current Team Member
I would guess a good half of the players listed with a team rating are unaffiliated.

I really wish I could skip these, and the GK database must know if they are current team members or not.

The green dot option would likely require additional processing, as I imagine the status for each player is computed when the team is displayed, instead of kept in a file.

What is the delay in implementing the current team filter? Why wouldn't team captains regard this as useful for searching for suitable opponents?
timjensen
12-Jan-19, 18:00

I agree. Why not have a button that will filter out players who currently have no team affiliation? It would make team recruitment more efficient.
lord_shiva
12-Jan-19, 20:48

Thanks, Hamot2!
I pop open 20 tabs at a time and close easily half. This is AFTER placing team limits from 1 to 5000, to weed out those players who have never been on a team.

I think about the bandwidth I'm wasting, and GK processor time, and wonder if other team captains have the same issue. GK HAS to know, pretty easily, and could populate the search screen with some radio check box so the team rating fields could be ignored.

The second request is for the green dot, but this could be trickier. GK might not know whether the player is on line at the moment in the database, but might instead have to do a look up, and that could be more CPU intensive. So I can certainly understand if that option isn't feasible. But the team option--they HAVE to know--it has got to be right there in the database.
lord_shiva
12-Jan-19, 20:50

Four Years
...and I've received no response on this.

Also, GK broke the profile photo several years ago, and hasn't fixed that either. My two pet peeves.

amacivn
13-Jan-19, 09:26

I'm not a Team Captain - but why do player's have a Team Rating if they are no longer in a Team ?

If they join another Team it's starts again anyway , what about a current Team Rating Button ?
tapanis
03-Apr-19, 10:00

Good Improvement
I'm voting for improving Advanced Player Search!
lord_shiva
03-Mar-24, 08:26

Tapanis
I love your little program. You should add a player team rating column.

lord_shiva
11-Apr-24, 10:39

Team Rating - Advanced Player Search & TOs
It is nice to know that they had a team rating. Players who had been on a team are easier to recruit.

A timeout flag should be on the game history screen. This one was someone else’s idea, but a good one. The little chessboard icon seems like wasted space, it should be obvious by the link indicator that you can click the win/loss.

My recommendation is that the board image be replaced by a clock to indicate games won or lost by timeout. It would be a pretty small, simple change, but would eliminate a captain’s need to examine every game to determine the cause for a string of losses, or if a recent rating decline was the result of timeouts.